This is something I’ve been meaning to write about for at least ten years but never did. This is mostly because I didn’t feel I had my thoughts together enough to get my point across — and I may yet fail in the attempt here. Though I think my purpose can be understood by the title alone if you’re familiar with both names.
One is a famous game designer and the other a famous film director. The former is considered a genius by many who play, write about or produce lengthy “video essays” about video games. The latter is considered a hack by many film critics but his films are generally financially successful and popular with general audiences. This difference in appreciation by critics in the two mediums matters because the style and themes both use in their works are very similar and nobody could reasonably deny that Kojima has taken obvious inspiration from Michael Bay films as well as plenty of similar films— particularly in the action genre. Yet, one is considered a genius in their medium while the other is considered a hack. Is this reasonable?
No, it isn’t.