A few years ago I wrote a post about on the Best Sim/Strategy category of the Game Awards, where it was clear that little diligence had been put into the nomination process. A few years have passed and little has changed with a remaster of the original 1997 PlayStation title Final Fantasy Tactics: The Ivalice Chronicles taking out that category at the 2025 Awards; the very day I began writing this post.
In reality, nobody really cares about the categories outside of overall ‘Game of the Year’ and many winners continue to be announced in the pre-show with very little fanfare. This year it was the French “JRPG” Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 that was the big winner; receiving the award in almost every category the game was nominated.
This included the two categories for Independent or “Indie” games which is questionable give the developers had a reasonably big publisher and a number of the developers formerly worked for Ubisoft. These two categories probably need to be more clearly defined as a smaller publisher than say Electronic Arts, Ubisoft or Activision — is still a publisher. In any case, I haven’t actually played this game so I can’t speak to its quality but it had a lot of buzz leading up to the show and the result is not a surprise.
UPDATE: (13/12/25) I’m far from the only one that was suspicious. This great article at Fandom Pulse is well worth your time.
Kingdom Come: Deliverance II was hilariously snubbed in every category though being nominated for three. As expected, the significant compromises they made to their original vision didn’t win them any “official” praise.
What was also noticed is that Sony Interactive Entertainment received nineteen nominations across the categories with Kepler Interactive (the publisher of Clair Obscur), receiving fourteen. There is a big drop between these two alone but it drops further and Nintendo received only four though it had a big year for new (and well-received) releases and did win in two of the categories it was nominated in.
This year was the twelfth Game Awards and so there are now twelve games of the year since 2014. I thought it would be worth going over these and offering some analysis. Though not for the winners for the last few years, hindsight has been quite instructive. Continue reading →